Best Sharpener For Colored Pencils: Top Brands Compared & Reviewed

Michael Daly
Written by
Last update:

Colored pencils are great, but let’s face it, they’re nothing without a pencil sharpener!

The best pencil sharpener for colored pencils will not only sharpen your crayons to a fine point, it will also keep them from breaking, and enable you to create a sharp point in 2 ways:

For soft tips: sharpening ends of pencils by rotating handle counterclockwise by one turn

For harder tips: by rotating the sharpener in the opposite direction to quickly create a sharp point

Today we’re going to help you find the best sharpener for colored pencils that will not only sharpen your crayons, but also keep them from breaking.

NameCategoryProduct
Mobius & Ruppert Brass Round Double Hole SharpenerBest OverallMobius & Ruppert Brass Round Double Hole Sharpener
STAEDTLER pencil sharpenerBudget PickSTAEDTLER pencil sharpener
Bostitch Antimicrobial QuietSharp Glow Extra Heavy Duty Classroom Electric Pencil SharpenerUpgrade PickBostitch Antimicrobial QuietSharp Glow Extra Heavy Duty Classroom Electric Pencil Sharpener

1. Mobius & Ruppert Brass Round Double Hole Sharpener

Our rating: 10 / 10

Mobius & Ruppert Brass Round Double Hole Sharpener

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Pack of two
  • Features 2 holes
  • Suitable for both small or large pastels
  • Brass design
  • Replacement blades available

Cons:

  • Very expensive

If you prefer a manual pencil sharpener, then you’ll likely love the Mobius & Ruppert. It’s graced with a hefty feel and offers a design that makes it easy to operate even if you’ve never sharpened a pencil before in your life.
The sharpener works with standard and colored pencils and has two different settings. The sharpener has two different holes for different sizes of pencils, so you can adjust it depending on what you want to sharpen.

2. Alvin, 9866

Our rating: 9 / 10

Alvin, 9866

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Solid brass bullet-shaped construction
  • Replaceable stainless steel cutting blade
  • Cuts both colored and graphite lead
  • Knurled finger grips
  • Fits standard 5/16-inch diameter pencils
  • Quickly and easily sharpens the tip

Cons:

  • Some complaint of a dull blade
  • Breaks the tip very often

If you love colored pencils, then you ought to get the best pencil sharpener that'll keep them sharp and ready to use. A good sharpener will help your favorite pencils last longer.
Alvin makes some of the best pencil sharpeners available on the market. This sharpener comes with replaceable blades that one can replace after use. You can adjust the blades using the custom blade clamp to minimize breakage. When the blades get dull, you can simply replace them, making the sharpener last longer.

3. Prismacolor Premier Pencil Sharpener

Our rating: 8 / 10

Prismacolor Premier Pencil Sharpener

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Optimized for Prismacolor Art Stix
  • Two separate blades for sharpening
  • One hole to sharpen to a fine point for detailed artwork, the other sharpens to a medium point for coverage
  • Separate blades for fine and medium points
  • Sharpener cover keeps shavings inside
  • Translucent body to see when full
  • Removable lid for easy cleaning

Cons:

  • Poor-quality plastic
  • Hard to open cover for removing shavings

The Prismacolor Premier pencil sharpener has unique blades that are calibrated for Prismacolor Premier colored pencils. This makes it the best sharpener for colored pencils to use on Art Stix or Prismacolor pencils. The design of the blades prevents oversharpening, which is a problem with some other sharpeners.

The pencil sharpener also features a unique safety lid that stops the sharpener from operating when the enclosure is removed. This means that you can sharpen pencils without worrying about sharp points emerging. The sharpener is safe, secure, and easy to use.

The sharpener includes a receptacle to catch pencil shavings. This makes it very easy to empty and prevents any mess from happening on your desk. The sharpener accepts several sizes of pencil, right down to the tiny specialty lead pencils. This makes it the best sharpener for colored pencils to use on Art Stix or Prismacolor pencils.

4. Bostitch QuietSharp 6 Heavy Duty Classroom Electric Pencil Sharpener

Our rating: 8 / 10

Bostitch QuietSharp 6 Heavy Duty Classroom Electric Pencil Sharpener

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Very quiet motor
  • 70% fasterStall free operation
  • Sharpens, then vacuums up shavings, all in one step
  • Six holes
  • Large shaving bin
  • Tip saver technology to prevent over-sharpening
  • Suction cups for stability
  • Suitable for classroom

Cons:

  • Fuser jams easily
  • Not durable
  • Sharpens one side leaving the other side covered in wood

Designed for use in the classroom, the Bostitch QuietSharp 6 Station pencil sharpener is designed to be countertop or wall-mounted and is very quiet, so it’s not distracting to students.
It has a powerful motor that can sharpen most standard-sized pencils easily. The sharpener also includes a vacuum chamber to catch shavings, so they’re not a mess on the classroom floor. The shavings chamber is a bit on the small side, so you may want to consider letting the shavings out periodically.

5. Staedtler Metal Sharpeners

Our rating: 8 / 10

Staedtler Metal Sharpeners

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Blade fastened in 3 places
  • Double holes
  • 23 & 30-degree sharpening angles for clear & accurate lines
  • Great value for the price
  • Easy to use
  • Sharpens pencils quickly
  • Sturdy metal sharpener
  • Comes with two sharpeners: 1 for colored pencils and a second for standard pencils

Cons:

  • Breaks pencils frequently

These sharpeners are made with metal, unlike most plastic sharpeners. The sharpener is great for colored pencils. The sharpener’s cone shape ensures that you can sharpen any size of a pencil.

6. X-ACTO School Pro Classroom Electric Pencil Sharpener

Our rating: 8 / 10

X-ACTO School Pro Classroom Electric Pencil Sharpener

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Heavy-duty electric pencil sharpener
  • Durable construction
  • Quiet electric motor
  • Flyaway cutter system to prevent over-sharpening
  • Helical steel cutter
  • Cutter offers 33 times longer blade life
  • Adjustable for six pencil sizes
  • Large shaving bin

Cons:

  • Might not be suitable for all pencil types
  • Customers have reported issues with replacement parts

Your search for the best pencil sharpener is over with this one from X-ACTO. It features a powerful motor and sharpens pencils in seconds with no fuss.
The X-ACTO School Pro Electric Pencil Sharpener could just be the solution to your dulling pencil woes. A well-sharpened pencil will glide across your page with ease and be comfortable in your hand.

One major thing we love about it is its range of capacities for pencil sizes. It can handle anything from dusting to standard to jumbo pencil sizes.

7. Tripworthy Electric Pencil Sharpener

Our rating: 8 / 10

Tripworthy Electric Pencil Sharpener

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Battery-powered efficient motor
  • Stainless steel helical blade
  • Kid-friendly auto-stop mechanism
  • Safe
  • High-quality, built to last for years
  • Comes with three different sharpening settings

Cons:

  • Poorly constructed
  • Battery burns out quickly

Tripworthy Electric Pencil Sharpener is great for coloring pencils of all sizes and is especially good for artists who work with colored pencils for coloring and shading for detailed artwork. This sharpener is an excellent value for money, especially since You can use it to sharpen colored and regular pencils.
What’s great about this sharpener is that your colored pencils will be automatically sharpened to a perfect point, which ensures that your artwork will turn out well. This sharpener is lightweight and compact enough for you to conveniently carry it wherever you go.

8. STAEDTLER pencil sharpener

Our rating: 8 / 10

STAEDTLER pencil sharpener

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Premium quality sharpener
  • Metal sharpener with secure screw-on lid
  • Assorted colors
  • Compact and portable
  • Perfect for a pencil case and work-station

Cons:

  • Not sturdy
  • Blade not angled correctly

This sharpener is small and compact, ideal for your pencil case, workspace, or otherwise. It's portable, making it ideal for artists on the go. It has a high satisfaction rate and is perfect for stashing in your pencil case.

9. Bostitch Antimicrobial QuietSharp Glow Extra Heavy Duty Classroom Electric Pencil Sharpener

Our rating: 8 / 10

Bostitch Antimicrobial QuietSharp Glow Extra Heavy Duty Classroom Electric Pencil Sharpener

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Six size selector dial
  • Antimicrobial cartridge
  • Classroom-friendly
  • Auto-stop prevents over-sharpening
  • Seven-year warranty
  • Accessories/add-ons like extra blades, spacers, and no-mar rubber feet are readily available
  • Tool-Free Replaceable Cutter
  • No assembly required

Cons:

  • Quits working after a few months
  • Not a quite sharpener, squeaks

The Bostitch QuietSharp Glow Electric Pencil Sharpener is in a league of its own. It's an extended-duty pencil sharpener that makes it easy and convenient to sharpen colored pencils. It's also the perfect pencil sharpener for most artists.
This pencil sharpener promises to sharpen your pencils to a perfect 7-10mm point while quietly and efficiently keeping your classmates and coworkers distraction-free.
This pencil sharpener also features a cartridge system that not only allows for a quick and easy replacement of blades but also keeps your child and surroundings safe with no microorganisms.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Which brand of colored pencils is best?

Prismacolor is the best-selling and the most well-known brand of colored pencils. Made in the USA, they come in a huge variety of colors and shades. They are soft and pigmented and go on almost smear-proof. Prismacolors are compatible with the most brands of mechanical pencils.

Faber-Castell is the one of the most expensive colored pencil brands out there. They come in a slightly lower range of colors than the Prismacolors but are still of high-quality. Faber-Castell pencils are not compatible with mechanical pencils and are more like graphite pencils than colored pencils. They are not as smudge-proof as Prismacolors.

What is the best pencil sharpener for Prismacolor pencils?

Prismacolor pencils are high-quality, and a dream to work with experienced artists. The Prismacolor Premier pencil sharpener has unique blades that are calibrated for Prismacolor Premier colored pencils. This makes it the best sharpener for colored pencils to use on Art Stix or Prismacolor pencils. The design of the blades prevents oversharpening, which is a problem with some other sharpeners.

Do colored pencils ruin electric sharpeners?

Because of the soft lead used in colored pencils, it’s nearly impossible to over-sharpen them unless you are sharpening the pencils like the lead is graphite. You can sharpen colored pencils in any manual or electric sharpener. However, if you have a colored pencil sharpener also intended for graphite pencils and over-sharpen the colored pencils, it may, but unlikely, ruin the inner workings of the sharpener.

The best advice is to be patient and get the exact angle you need for the perfect sharp line. Most sharpeners can be adjusted to produce a sharp angled edge. If not, they can usually be honed to do so with a knife. It’s worth it to learn how to sharpen pencils this way in order to get the perfect point.

Does soaking colored pencils make them better?

Contrary to what most people believe, soaking your colored pencils does NOT sharpen them. It may sharpen the point, but it breaks down the lead inside. This is especially bad for soft colored pencils, as the pigment will leak into the wood and create a damp blank spot in the lead. Always sharpen your pencils before you use them then coat the point with your pencil extender/conditioner so it won’t break when you sharpen.

Some people say they see a difference when they soak their pencils. The truth is that most of the soak-before-you-sharpen advocates are the same ones who also advocate sharpening colored pencils on broken wine glasses!

Conclusion

When searching for a colored pencil sharpener, there are several things to look for. Our reviews take you straight to the best colored pencil sharpeners and explain the differences between models. We also cover some handy tips for using your colored pencil sharpener to ensure it is used and cared for properly. The main thing to remember is that these sharpeners can create beautiful artwork but only if used correctly and maintained.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
Mobius & Ruppert Brass Round Double Hole SharpenerBest OverallMobius & Ruppert Brass Round Double Hole Sharpener
STAEDTLER pencil sharpenerBudget PickSTAEDTLER pencil sharpener
Bostitch Antimicrobial QuietSharp Glow Extra Heavy Duty Classroom Electric Pencil SharpenerUpgrade PickBostitch Antimicrobial QuietSharp Glow Extra Heavy Duty Classroom Electric Pencil Sharpener