10 Best Pencil Erasers That Will Cleanly Remove Marks

Michael Daly
Written by
Last update:

A pencil eraser provides a way to quickly clean up mistakes, marks, and smudges on paper without wrecking the page. It is an economical and environmentally friendly way to recover from errors and to sharpen pencils when they have become dull.

If you write a lot, you probably use a pencil eraser on a near daily basis.

In fact, you probably have some nearby right now!

However, if you are like most people, that little pink eraser has a serious limitation in that it often smudges and smears rather than removing your marks. This can make it hard to read your writing for the next person to use the pencil.

Don't worry though…

We have a list of ten best pencil erasers that will have you saying goodbye to smears and hello to clean and easy erasing.

Sakura Arch Evolutional Foam ErasersBest OverallSakura Arch Evolutional Foam Erasers
Pentel Ain Regular Size EraserBudget PickPentel Ain Regular Size Eraser
Tombow 67304 MONO Sand EraserUpgrade PickTombow 67304 MONO Sand Eraser

1. Sakura Arch Evolutional Foam Erasers

Our rating: 9 / 10

Sakura Arch Evolutional Foam Erasers

Check Price on Amazon


  • Sell at a great price point
  • Rubber grip
  • Very few chemical odors when first received
  • Quite durable eraser
  • Produces minimal waste


  • Fragile packaging
  • May be a bit too narrow for some users
  • Not a very long time span

As the name suggests, erasers are intended to erase mistakes. Sometimes, however, mistakes are made by the eraser. These erasers are made in Japan and are very popular. They're made entirely of foam. The bright white is also appealing to the eye.

Eraser tips vary in softness based on how old they are. The older ones tend to be softer, but they’re a little dirty and may have bits of paper wedged in between the foam. If you plan on doing a serious piece of drawing, these are good to keep around.

Use these erasers for rough sketches or mistakes in important drawings. They also work for technical drawings. The eraser does make a mess of your paper, however.

2. Tombow 67304 MONO Sand Eraser

Our rating: 9 / 10

Tombow 67304 MONO Sand Eraser

Check Price on Amazon


  • Removes markings accurately and easily
  • Use the correct erasing surface to maintain the quality of your art
  • Comes in the form of a reusable eraser
  • Can use on colored and even black paper
  • Contains no drying agents


  • Cannot be used as an eraser for regular pencils
  • Cannot be sharpened like a regular pencil eraser

Tombow MONO sand eraser is a leading pencil eraser that has been around for over 50 years. In addition to erasing pencil markings, it can also erase pen, ink, and colored pencils as well.

Its efficiency comes from the design of its resin eraser, which is arranged in a very thin sheet that makes the eraser capable of erasing a large section of the edge of the paper while minimizing damage to the other surface. It also comes in a pencil-like shape so you can store it conveniently just like a regular pencil. It’s a good thing it’s refillable too.

Though the Tombow MONO Sand Eraser certainly does its job by removing various markings, it’s not really designed for it. When sharpened, it breaks apart and will quickly become something that looks like an eraser shavings. A better alternative is a pencil eraser.

3. Pentel Ain Regular Size Eraser

Our rating: 8 / 10

Pentel Ain Regular Size Eraser

Check Price on Amazon


  • Gentle on both paper and hands
  • Dissolves on contact with light
  • Safe and non-toxic

If you’re wondering how to erase pencil marks with a regular portable mechanical pencil, then look no further than the Pentel Ain. This is hands down one of the best pencil erasers you can get.

It is a manual eraser that can be used to erase either graphite or lead pencil marks. It is very effective in removing pencil marks, especially on paper. The eraser itself is a 6mm eraser made from lightweight white plastic with blue trim.

It is neither messy nor toxic because it simply turns to permanent dust when in contact with paper. Therefore, you don’t have to worry about the eraser leaving remnants on your paper (or on you!).

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What brand of eraser is most effective in removing pencil marks?

There are many different kinds of erasers on the market today, and finding one that is both effective and meets your specific needs can be quite a challenge.

First and foremost, you want to look for an eraser that can remove both graphite and colored marks. Most are unfortunately quite ineffective at removing colored marks.

The next feature to consider is the eraser material itself. Some are made from synthetic materials which can actually damage your paper. Rubbing too hard can result in little holes being made, causing your paper to look like it is starting to tan. It can also damage your paper by leaving behind small fibers for you to see.

Finally, and most importantly, you will want to find an eraser that is safe to use on your paper. Certain materials can potentially cause irreversible damage to your paper. You will want to be very cautious when choosing an eraser.

How do you get pencil marks off without eraser?

So maybe you've chewed all of yours into little pieces, or maybe you just like writing with pencils, but either way, that pesky bane of pencil users everywhere, a pencil with a gone eraser, is looming closer and closer with each use. Your heart pounds as you gaze over the top and bottom of the pencil, searching for remnants of white graphite to suggest that you're in the clear. And then there it is! Just a bit of white on the side. You cautiously turn the pencil to the angle you think is suitable, but it falls short of accomplishing the task. There should be no excuses when it comes to erasing a mistake! Here are 10 of the best pencil erasers that should stand up to their end of the deal.

What is the best type of eraser?

The best erasers are the type that won’t cause smudges. This is where erase sticks or erasable fiber tips come in handy because they cleanly erase marks without smearing. This type of eraser is ideal for people who use pencils and need to erase large amounts of work.

Other types of eraser that have their uses are the traditional rubber block eraser. However, you can’t erase as much work at one time. The eraser also wears out faster, and this can be a drawback for those who need to erase a lot of writing.

For those who use mechanical pencils, eraser refills make it easy to change worn out erasers. Ink erasers are also available for those who use ink pens often. These erase ink without smearing, but they’re not very good at removing pencil markings.

How do you rejuvenate pencil erasers?

This is a question for the ages. I can’t speak for all pencil erasers, but I can speak for the ones I’ve tested. Generally, if you leave it out in the sun with the top facing up, it will clean itself.

Most pencil erasers are made with a porous surface. If you leave it in the sun with that top-facing-up for enough time, the pencil eraser is presumably porous enough to allow UV rays, oxygen, and a few other gases in.


When it comes to your pencil eraser, there are several important things you need to know. The first is what makes for a quality eraser. Second, you want to consider frequency of use. Third, you will need to consider the natural character of your eraser. And finally, you want to make sure your eraser works effectively.

Our Recommendation

Sakura Arch Evolutional Foam ErasersBest OverallSakura Arch Evolutional Foam Erasers
Pentel Ain Regular Size EraserBudget PickPentel Ain Regular Size Eraser
Tombow 67304 MONO Sand EraserUpgrade PickTombow 67304 MONO Sand Eraser