5 Best Erasable Colored Pencils Reviewed

Michael Daly
Written by
Last update:

Are you looking for the best erasable colored pencils on the market? If so, hopefully you’ll find the answers you’ve been searching for on this page.

My name is Marty, and I’m a professional coloring artist. I’ve been working with coloring for almost 22 years. I color every day and love coloring for relaxation, fun and to help relieve stress.

Coloring appeals to everyone regardless of age or skill level, it can even be therapeutic for some people, and it’s no longer just for kids! All kinds of people enjoy this fun hobby.

If you are a coloring enthusiast like me, then you’ve probably tried hundreds of colored pencils. Then you learned that some colored pencils aren’t so great. They break or smudge when you are coloring and they are usually pretty expensive.

I will show you the best erasable colored pencil sets for the money you spend on this page.

NameCategoryProduct
Prismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored PencilBest OverallPrismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored Pencil
Crayola Erasable Colored PencilsBudget PickCrayola Erasable Colored Pencils
Pilot Frixion Eraseable Colored Pencil 12 ColorsUpgrade PickPilot Frixion Eraseable Colored Pencil 12 Colors

1. Prismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored Pencil

Our rating: 9 / 10

Prismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored Pencil

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Pack of 24 colored pencils with erasers
  • Ideal for adult coloring projects
  • Fully erasable
  • Premium pigment for rich, smooth color
  • Medium point resists cracking and breaking
  • Easily colors over with graphite as it’s sharpened
  • Fun to use
  • Can be used on coarse and finely grained paper
  • Good value for money

Cons:

  • Not much blendable
  • Completely erasable only if you have a soft drawing hand
  • Can dull quickly

If you’re a pencil fan, then you’re probably already familiar with Prismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored Pencils. These amazing colored pencils can be sharpened to a wide range of tips and allow you to cover them over with graphite as you sharpen them easily.

The Prismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored Pencils come with four different tips: fine, medium, broad, and soft, as well as a dedicated eraser on the back end of the pencil.

These pencils are truly versatile and can be used for a wide range of artistic applications. Because they’re so useful and versatile, it’s easy to forget how easy it is to use them for traditional coloring. You can also buy them in a variety of different colors.

2. Tombow 51528 Irojiten Colored Pencil Set

Our rating: 8 / 10

Tombow 51528 Irojiten Colored Pencil Set

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Twelve colored pencils, a sharpener, and a colored pencil eraser.
  • Available in two pre-sorted color selections – Vivid and tranquil
  • Strong pigment
  • Comes with a perfectly thick and sturdy case for storage and to prevent breakage
  • Perfect for use on a variety of surfaces
  • Excellent pencil for beginners

Cons:

  • Very hard lead
  • Do not always erase well

If you want vibrant colored pencils, but don’t want to break the bank, then this exciting pencil set from Tombow is one to consider. It’s a new take on an old favorite, and the results are rather impressive.

The Irojiten Colored Pencil Set from Tombow have excellent pigment, so they’re great for inking, sketching, planning, and lots of other tasks. The colors are vivid, clean, bright, and go on smoothly. Of course, they’re ideal for coloring, but one can also use them for projects at work or home.

3. Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils

Our rating: 8 / 10

Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils

Check Price on Amazon

Cons:

  • The quality of pigment could be better
  • Very waxy and don't color very well

Color, erase, and start over again! With Crayola’s colored pencils, you can do this and save yourself the expense of wasting your time buying brand new colored pencils over and over again.

If you’re careful with them and don’t leave them lying around for your little ones, this can be an excellent product for you.

4. Pilot Frixion Eraseable Colored Pencil 12 Colors

Our rating: 7 / 10

Pilot Frixion Eraseable Colored Pencil 12 Colors

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Lightweight
  • 12 amazing colors
  • Erase quickly and cleanly
  • Each pencil has an erasable tip
  • Strong pigment
  • Amazing colors
  • No messy eraser shavings

Cons:

  • Need to press hard as color is faint
  • Can break easily if sharpened to a very sharp point due to soft lead

Expanding on the Frixion erasable pens, we decided to cover erasable colored pencils. These pencils are a bit different than the average colored pencil. The erasable quality is great for not making any mistakes other than starting your drawing over again.

However, the erasable quality does mean that when you’re erasing, you get a lot of shavings dropping out of the pencil, which can be annoying. Still, the erasing tip provided with pencils solves this problem.

5. Staedtler Erasable Colored Pencils

Our rating: 7 / 10

Staedtler Erasable Colored Pencils

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • 12 colors-erasable pre-sharpened
  • Anti-breaking coating covers the entire length of the lead to prevent lead breakage
  • German manufactured
  • Brilliant colors
  • Easy to sharpen

Cons:

  • Graphite is thin
  • Low-quality wood used

Not that you need them, but here are a few more reasons to love this set of colored pencils. The set comes with eraser tips. They’re also very affordable. Staedtler is a Swedish product that lasts for a long time.

The package includes twelve colors. You do have to adjust to using them, but you’ll fall in love with the Staedtler colored pencils once you do.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Which brand of colored pencils is the best?

If you want the best and most professional quality colored pencils, then Prismacolor colored pencils are the ones for you. Their color is very vivid and incredible for anything from drawings to coloring. They are also easier to blend than most colored pencils and will create a dazzling picture for you.

If you want some that are a little less expensive than Crayola, colored pencils are going to be the best for you. They have a very smooth consistency and blend amazingly well.

If you only want them for small projects, the Sanford Brands Colored Pencils are the best option. They will be more affordable, and the quality isn’t going to be degraded by using them for smaller projects.

Are colored pencils erasable?

Yes, you can erase colored pencils. The pencils that use wax are the erasable ones. You can even erase the colored pencil pencils if you use a good solvent-based or alcohol-based eraser.

However, just because the colored pencil is erasable does not mean that it erases easily. The eraser may smear the color rather than erasing it.
Colored pencils are not the favorite among most professional artists or designers. Instead, they are used for coloring by children (which is what colored pencils are essentially for anyway). They are also used to revise sketches made in ink.

Does soaking colored pencils make them better?

No soaking colored pencils do not make them better. Dry colored pencils offer artists more versatility, control, and last longer all while keeping the pencil relatively less damaged as you draw or color. However, soaking colored pencils in warm water does produce a highly saturated or heavily pigmented effect that can embolden sections throughout your picture.

Why do colored pencils not erase?

While colored pencils aren't as easy to erase as graphite pencils, they can still be erased should the need arise. However, the ones that are erasable provide a superior result, they can be used to produce a very smooth image and can be blended easily.
You must remember this is a coloring pencil and not a sketch pencil. These pencils have a lot of wax in them. This makes them water-resistant and even eraser-resistant, making the colors stay long after they are applied.

Conclusion

There are no perfect erasable colored pencils. It is a tradeoff between quality and cost. However, there are a few brands that offer products that are better than others. You can choose from the Crayola colored pencils that are inexpensive and get the job done or the Prismacolor brand that is a little more expensive but offers a higher quality of the product.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
Prismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored PencilBest OverallPrismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored Pencil
Crayola Erasable Colored PencilsBudget PickCrayola Erasable Colored Pencils
Pilot Frixion Eraseable Colored Pencil 12 ColorsUpgrade PickPilot Frixion Eraseable Colored Pencil 12 Colors